Information verified and updated: 18 November 2026
Neither is better for every building. A flat one is usually cheaper and quicker to build and suits extensions, garages and dormers. A pitched roof sheds water faster, lasts longer and gives you loft space. This guide compares the two on cost, lifespan, maintenance and planning, based on the roofs we repair and replace across London.
It isn't completely flat. It has a slight fall, usually just a few degrees, so rain runs to a gutter or outlet. In UK building standards, a roof is generally treated as flat if its slope is under 10 degrees. Anything steeper is a pitched roof, covered with overlapping tiles or slates rather than a continuous waterproof membrane.
Slope under 10°. A continuous membrane: EPDM rubber, GRP fibreglass, felt or lead.
Slope of more than 10°, usually much steeper on London houses. Overlapping slates or tiles on battens and underlay.
| Flat | Pitched | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost to build | Usually lower: less structure and fewer materials | Usually higher: rafters, more roof area, scaffolding |
| Lifespan | 15–20 years (felt), 30–40 (GRP), 40–50 (EPDM) | Concrete tiles and clay tiles last for decades; natural slate longer still |
| Drainage | Slow. Relies on correct falls and clear outlets | Fast. Rain runs straight off |
| Maintenance | Keep outlets clear, check for ponding and splits | Check for slipped tiles, flashing and gutters |
| Space | Can be used as a terrace or for a green roof | Loft space for storage or a conversion |
| Where it's used | Extensions, garages, dormers, back additions | The main roof on most London houses |
Cheaper and quicker to build. Easy and safe to inspect. Suits modern extensions, and can be used as a terrace or green roof. Modern EPDM and GRP last far longer than the old felt roofs that gave them a bad name.
Water drains more slowly, so poor falls or blocked outlets lead to ponding and leaks. Felt roofs have a much shorter life. Most problems start at upstands and wall junctions if they weren't detailed properly.
Read more: flat roof installation and why flat roofs leak.
Sheds rain and snow quickly. Slate and clay tiles last for a very long time. Creates loft space and suits the look of most London streets, which matters in conservation areas.
Costs more to build and replace, mostly because of the structure, roof area and scaffolding. Repairs need access equipment, and slipped tiles or failed flashing can go unnoticed for a while.
Read more: pitched roof repairs, slate roofs and tile roofs.
To build, usually yes. It needs less timber, less roof covering and often no scaffolding on a ground-floor extension. Over the life of the building the gap narrows, because felt may need replacing several times in the life of one slate roof. That's why EPDM or GRP is usually the better value.
Pitched tile roof replacement starts from £4,899 and slate from £4,999. Flat roofs are priced individually after a survey; see our flat roof cost guide for what affects the price, or our guide to the different types of roof replacement.
Yes. Converting one is common on garages and extensions with recurring leaks. It changes the height and shape of the building, so it usually needs planning permission and Building Regulations approval, and the walls and structure must be able to take the extra load. Check the Planning Portal or ask your council before committing.
Often the simpler fix is to re-cover it in EPDM or GRP and correct the falls, which solves the leaks without planning issues.
A roof with a slope of less than 10 degrees is generally treated as flat and is covered with a continuous membrane. Above that, it's a pitched roof covered with overlapping tiles or slates.
For extensions, garages and dormers, a modern flat roof is often the better choice. For the main roof of a house, a pitched roof drains faster, lasts longer and adds loft space.
Usually cheaper to build, as it needs less structure and material. Over the long term, the cost depends on how long the flat roof lasts, so EPDM or GRP is better value than felt.
They're more sensitive to poor workmanship, because water drains slowly. A well-detailed EPDM or GRP roof with correct falls and clear outlets shouldn't leak.
Felt lasts 15–20 years, GRP 30–40 and EPDM 40–50. Concrete and clay tiles last for decades and natural slate even longer.
Yes, but it usually needs planning permission and Building Regulations approval, and the structure must take the extra weight.
We repair and replace both, so we'll recommend what suits the building. Free survey, no call-out charge.